Skip to content
Claim explanation
Looking for an earlier statement?
An older link to this address referred to a different statement. The Boise reservoirs' size is not what they hold today.

In one example, 1,000 acre-feet of credit saved the aquifer 400

Ready to paste into a message or email.

Copy this address: https://idahowaterstatus.com/research/claims/CLM-000017

The short answer

Spent on industry, the credit would leave the aquifer 600 acre-feet worse off.

The example comes from a 2009 University of Idaho study of groundwater banking. Someone stops flood irrigating 200 acres that used to get 5 feet of water and earns a credit for 1,000 acre-feet. An acre-foot is enough water to cover an acre one foot deep, about 326,000 gallons. But 600 acre-feet of that water would have seeped back into the aquifer anyway. The aquifer gains only the 400 acre-feet that the irrigation would have consumed.

Now suppose the credit pays for 1,000 acre-feet of industrial use that consumes all of its water. The aquifer, and the people who draw on it, lose 600 acre-feet more than before. The numbers illustrate the problem and come from no real trade. The study backs counting every credit by its net effect on the aquifer. Then a buyer would not have to dig into how each credit was earned.

Research details and original wording

Record reference: CLM-000017

Original statement

An illustrative exchange credits 1,000 acre-feet of forgone irrigation diversion that benefits the aquifer by only 400 acre-feet. Redeeming it for 1,000 acre-feet of fully consumptive use increases net extraction by 600 acre-feet. The author consequently favors credits based on net aquifer impact.

extracted
preliminary
Human review required
Claim details
Primary geography
Unknown
Time period covered
August 2009 report; hypothetical example.
Metric
Diversion, net aquifer benefit and incremental net extraction in a hypothetical exchange.
Unit
Acre-feet; 1,000 − 400 = 600 acre-feet under the stated assumptions.
Caveat
Historical methods, modeled quantities and illustrative scenarios do not establish present observations, transferable credits or legal availability.
Why it matters
Not recorded
Verification needed
P07/P14 method and version review; verify operative rules and source data before any accounting or administrative application.
Geographies

No geographies linked yet.

Tests hypotheses

Not linked to a hypothesis yet.

Documentary qualifications

Original wording is preserved below. Source attribution is not independent verification. Missing information is shown as Unknown.

Documentary claim ID
CLM-000017
Original claim text
An illustrative exchange credits 1,000 acre-feet of forgone irrigation diversion that benefits the aquifer by only 400 acre-feet. Redeeming it for 1,000 acre-feet of fully consumptive use increases net extraction by 600 acre-feet. The author consequently favors credits based on net aquifer impact.
Original source ID
SRC-000082
Source owner
IWRRI, University of Idaho; author Bryce A. Contor; Reclamation-funded project.
Authority tier
Tier 3 - Scientific/technical synthesis
Claim type
Historical technical methods and scope
Original geography
Upper Snake / ESPA accounting example; no identified transaction.
Original time period
August 2009 report; hypothetical example.
Original metric
Diversion, net aquifer benefit and incremental net extraction in a hypothetical exchange.
Original unit
Acre-feet; 1,000 − 400 = 600 acre-feet under the stated assumptions.
Water accounting type
Diversion,Consumptive use,Depletion.
Legal instrument type
UNKNOWN; technical report, not an operative instrument
Preliminary confidence
High for the cited text; visual formula review and current application unverified
Original caveat
Historical methods, modeled quantities and illustrative scenarios do not establish present observations, transferable credits or legal availability.
Original verification needed
P07/P14 method and version review; verify operative rules and source data before any accounting or administrative application.
Evidence for the claim
Chapter 7, printed/PDF [page 53](https://objects.lib.uidaho.edu/iwdl/iwdl-200906.pdf#page=53). This is an illustrative accounting scenario, not an observed saving or approved credit rate. Source record: SRC-000082; canonical URL: https://www.lib.uidaho.edu/digital/iwdl/items/iwdl-200906.html. Provenance: [Original CLM-000017](et_and_groundwater_banking_reports_extraction.md#clm-000017), original line 93. Consolidated September 29, 2026; original fields and scientific confidence retained, no new scientific verification.
Evidence against and limitations
No contradiction identified for these narrow textual claims; no independent model run or implementation validation performed.
Related basin
Upper Snake / ESPA.
Related cross-cutting systems
models,accounting,measurement,governance
Original documentary status
Preliminary; selected report text inspected
Sources behind this statement
A 2009 study of groundwater banking in the Upper Snake

preliminary_claims.jsonl#CLM-000017