In one example, 1,000 acre-feet of credit saved the aquifer 400
Ready to paste into a message or email.
Copy this address: https://idahowaterstatus.com/research/claims/CLM-000017
The short answer
Spent on industry, the credit would leave the aquifer 600 acre-feet worse off.
The example comes from a 2009 University of Idaho study of groundwater banking. Someone stops flood irrigating 200 acres that used to get 5 feet of water and earns a credit for 1,000 acre-feet. An acre-foot is enough water to cover an acre one foot deep, about 326,000 gallons. But 600 acre-feet of that water would have seeped back into the aquifer anyway. The aquifer gains only the 400 acre-feet that the irrigation would have consumed.
Now suppose the credit pays for 1,000 acre-feet of industrial use that consumes all of its water. The aquifer, and the people who draw on it, lose 600 acre-feet more than before. The numbers illustrate the problem and come from no real trade. The study backs counting every credit by its net effect on the aquifer. Then a buyer would not have to dig into how each credit was earned.
Research details and original wording
Record reference: CLM-000017
Original statement
An illustrative exchange credits 1,000 acre-feet of forgone irrigation diversion that benefits the aquifer by only 400 acre-feet. Redeeming it for 1,000 acre-feet of fully consumptive use increases net extraction by 600 acre-feet. The author consequently favors credits based on net aquifer impact.
- Primary geography
- Unknown
- Time period covered
- August 2009 report; hypothetical example.
- Metric
- Diversion, net aquifer benefit and incremental net extraction in a hypothetical exchange.
- Unit
- Acre-feet; 1,000 − 400 = 600 acre-feet under the stated assumptions.
- Caveat
- Historical methods, modeled quantities and illustrative scenarios do not establish present observations, transferable credits or legal availability.
- Why it matters
- Not recorded
- Verification needed
- P07/P14 method and version review; verify operative rules and source data before any accounting or administrative application.
No geographies linked yet.
Not linked to a hypothesis yet.
Original wording is preserved below. Source attribution is not independent verification. Missing information is shown as Unknown.
- Documentary claim ID
- CLM-000017
- Original claim text
- An illustrative exchange credits 1,000 acre-feet of forgone irrigation diversion that benefits the aquifer by only 400 acre-feet. Redeeming it for 1,000 acre-feet of fully consumptive use increases net extraction by 600 acre-feet. The author consequently favors credits based on net aquifer impact.
- Original source ID
- SRC-000082
- Source owner
- IWRRI, University of Idaho; author Bryce A. Contor; Reclamation-funded project.
- Authority tier
- Tier 3 - Scientific/technical synthesis
- Claim type
- Historical technical methods and scope
- Original geography
- Upper Snake / ESPA accounting example; no identified transaction.
- Original time period
- August 2009 report; hypothetical example.
- Original metric
- Diversion, net aquifer benefit and incremental net extraction in a hypothetical exchange.
- Original unit
- Acre-feet; 1,000 − 400 = 600 acre-feet under the stated assumptions.
- Water accounting type
- Diversion,Consumptive use,Depletion.
- Legal instrument type
- UNKNOWN; technical report, not an operative instrument
- Preliminary confidence
- High for the cited text; visual formula review and current application unverified
- Original caveat
- Historical methods, modeled quantities and illustrative scenarios do not establish present observations, transferable credits or legal availability.
- Original verification needed
- P07/P14 method and version review; verify operative rules and source data before any accounting or administrative application.
- Evidence for the claim
- Chapter 7, printed/PDF [page 53](https://objects.lib.uidaho.edu/iwdl/iwdl-200906.pdf#page=53). This is an illustrative accounting scenario, not an observed saving or approved credit rate. Source record: SRC-000082; canonical URL: https://www.lib.uidaho.edu/digital/iwdl/items/iwdl-200906.html. Provenance: [Original CLM-000017](et_and_groundwater_banking_reports_extraction.md#clm-000017), original line 93. Consolidated September 29, 2026; original fields and scientific confidence retained, no new scientific verification.
- Evidence against and limitations
- No contradiction identified for these narrow textual claims; no independent model run or implementation validation performed.
- Related basin
- Upper Snake / ESPA.
- Related cross-cutting systems
- models,accounting,measurement,governance
- Original documentary status
- Preliminary; selected report text inspected
preliminary_claims.jsonl#CLM-000017