Skip to content
Claim explanation

Big Lost River storage estimates are highly uncertain

Ready to paste into a message or email.

Copy this address: https://idahowaterstatus.com/research/claims/CLM-000050

The short answer

Below Mackay Dam, estimates of stored groundwater change rest on few wells and one assumption with a wide range.

For dry 2013, the report estimated the change in stored groundwater in the middle part of the basin, above the Moore Diversion. The estimate ran from 15,700 to 472,000 acre-feet. An acre-foot is enough water to cover an acre one foot deep. The range is that wide because of one assumption. Below Mackay Dam, the report mapped yearly water levels between wells and subtracted one year’s map from the next. It multiplied that change by an assumed specific yield of 0.01 to 0.3. Specific yield describes how much water an aquifer releases as the water table falls.

The report calls the results highly uncertain. Few wells cover the area, and results changed when certain wells were added or left out. It also says these estimates cannot be compared directly with the gap between estimated inflow and outflow in the groundwater budget. The two methods cover different areas, and water levels rise some time after recharge, while the budget assumes recharge arrives at once.

Research details and original wording

Record reference: CLM-000050

Original statement

The separate below-dam storage assessment interpolates annual groundwater levels and applies assumed specific yield of 0.01–0.3. The authors call the results highly uncertain and say they cannot be directly compared with budget residuals because analysis areas and recharge timing differ.

extracted
preliminary
Human review required
Claim details
Primary geography
Unknown
Time period covered
2000–19 storage comparison.
Metric
Storage-estimation assumptions and comparability.
Unit
Assumed specific yield 0.01–0.3, dimensionless; no new storage volume calculated.
Caveat
Historical and scale-dependent evidence; no current allocation, sustainable yield, parcel effect or drinking-water conclusion. Visual verification incomplete.
Why it matters
Not recorded
Verification needed
P06 versions/components; P07/P08/P14/P21/P29 hydrologic methods, monitoring coverage, spatial evidence and later Big Lost research
Geographies

No geographies linked yet.

Tests hypotheses

Not linked to a hypothesis yet.

Documentary qualifications

Original wording is preserved below. Source attribution is not independent verification. Missing information is shown as Unknown.

Documentary claim ID
CLM-000050
Original claim text
The separate below-dam storage assessment interpolates annual groundwater levels and applies assumed specific yield of 0.01–0.3. The authors call the results highly uncertain and say they cannot be directly compared with budget residuals because analysis areas and recharge timing differ.
Original source ID
SRC-000093
Source owner
USGS publication; Clark, Idaho Geological Survey, with IDWR.
Authority tier
Tier 3 - Scientific/technical synthesis
Claim type
Historical research finding or method/lineage finding
Original geography
Big Lost basin below Mackay Dam; contrasting limited coverage above the dam.
Original time period
2000–19 storage comparison.
Original metric
Storage-estimation assumptions and comparability.
Original unit
Assumed specific yield 0.01–0.3, dimensionless; no new storage volume calculated.
Water accounting type
Storage,Recharge
Legal instrument type
UNKNOWN; research publication, not an operative legal instrument
Preliminary confidence
Moderate for attributed report findings; stated release counts independently checked, original measurements and models not reproduced
Original caveat
Historical and scale-dependent evidence; no current allocation, sustainable yield, parcel effect or drinking-water conclusion. Visual verification incomplete.
Original verification needed
P06 versions/components; P07/P08/P14/P21/P29 hydrologic methods, monitoring coverage, spatial evidence and later Big Lost research
Evidence for the claim
Printed 49 ([PDF 63](https://pubs.usgs.gov/sir/2021/5078/c/sir20215078C.pdf#page=63)), storage-method discussion, coverage limitations and direct-comparison warning. Source record: SRC-000093; canonical URL: https://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/sir20215078C. Provenance: [Original CLM-000050](big_lost_water_resources_characterization_extraction.md#clm-000050), original line 62. Consolidated September 29, 2026; original fields and scientific confidence retained, no new scientific verification.
Evidence against and limitations
Sparse and incomplete well coverage, sensitivity to selected wells and specific yield, recharge lag, omitted unsaturated storage and unassessed bedrock storage prevent treating this as independent confirmation of the budget residual.
Related basin
Big Lost River Valley aquifer.
Related cross-cutting systems
measurement,accounting,models
Original documentary status
Preliminary; selected text and release data inspected, access and interpretation limits retained
Sources behind this statement
What recharges and drains the Big Lost River aquifer

preliminary_claims.jsonl#CLM-000050