Skip to content
Claim explanation

The Rathdrum Prairie model is not meant to trace contaminants

Ready to paste into a message or email.

Copy this address: https://idahowaterstatus.com/research/claims/CLM-000062

The short answer

The 2007 model also lacks the detail to map one well’s water source.

The U.S. Geological Survey and its partners built this 2007 model of the Spokane Valley-Rathdrum Prairie aquifer for water-supply questions across the whole aquifer. The report says it “is not intended” for predicting how long contaminants take to travel or what paths they follow. A model for that would need “a substantially greater amount” of detail about the ground and groundwater at the contamination site.

A capture zone is the area that supplies water to a well. The model lacks the detail to map one directly, though it might help set boundaries for a smaller, local study. The report also says fitting the model to measurements cannot reliably tell how much groundwater flows in from Spirit and Hoodoo valleys. The model assumes none. Yet a version with 40 cubic feet per second (a flow rate) of inflow fit the data almost as well.

Research details and original wording

Record reference: CLM-000062

Original statement

The report limits direct use for individual-well capture zones and contaminant travel. Its assumed zero Spirit/Hoodoo inflow is not uniquely established by calibration.

extracted
preliminary
Human review required
Claim details
Primary geography
Unknown
Time period covered
Applicability of the historical model described in 2007.
Metric
Model scale and parameter-identification limits.
Unit
Qualitative applicability; zero inflow is an assumption.
Caveat
Historical estimates and assumptions do not establish current supply, individual-well impacts or legal availability. Full PDFs/media remain unread.
Why it matters
Not recorded
Verification needed
P06 identities/component versions; P07/P14/P21/P27 full reports, original measurements, plates and later models
Geographies

No geographies linked yet.

Tests hypotheses

Not linked to a hypothesis yet.

Documentary qualifications

Original wording is preserved below. Source attribution is not independent verification. Missing information is shown as Unknown.

Documentary claim ID
CLM-000062
Original claim text
The report limits direct use for individual-well capture zones and contaminant travel. Its assumed zero Spirit/Hoodoo inflow is not uniquely established by calibration.
Original source ID
SRC-000098
Source owner
USGS; Paul A. Hsieh and coauthors.
Authority tier
Tier 3 - Scientific/technical synthesis
Claim type
Historical report-method or model-input finding
Original geography
Spokane Valley-Rathdrum Prairie aquifer, Spokane County, Washington; Bonner and Kootenai Counties, Idaho
Original time period
Applicability of the historical model described in 2007.
Original metric
Model scale and parameter-identification limits.
Original unit
Qualitative applicability; zero inflow is an assumption.
Water accounting type
Modeled flow
Legal instrument type
UNKNOWN; research, not an operative legal instrument
Preliminary confidence
High for selected text/input structure; physical accuracy and present applicability unverified
Original caveat
Historical estimates and assumptions do not establish current supply, individual-well impacts or legal availability. Full PDFs/media remain unread.
Original verification needed
P06 identities/component versions; P07/P14/P21/P27 full reports, original measurements, plates and later models
Evidence for the claim
Table 1 E3; [Model Limitations and Suggestions for Future Work](https://pubs.usgs.gov/sir/2007/5044/section6.html), paragraphs 2–4, including alternative model D. Source record: SRC-000098; canonical URL: https://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/sir20075044. Provenance: [Original CLM-000062](svrp_framework_and_model_extraction.md#clm-000062), original line 71. Consolidated September 29, 2026; original fields and scientific confidence retained, no new scientific verification.
Evidence against and limitations
Overall calibration fit does not resolve these limitations; lower-unit hydraulic isolation and lake seepage also remain uncertain.
Related basin
Spokane / Coeur dAlene; Spokane Valley-Rathdrum Prairie aquifer
Related cross-cutting systems
measurement,models,accounting
Original documentary status
Preliminary; selected body/component inspection only
Sources behind this statement
A regional model for the Spokane–Rathdrum aquifer

preliminary_claims.jsonl#CLM-000062