Skip to content
Claim explanation

The Treasure Valley geology study’s well counts differ by one

Ready to paste into a message or email.

Copy this address: https://idahowaterstatus.com/research/claims/PILOT-CLM-009

The short answer

A 2019 federal report says it used 291 driller reports, but its released well files list 290 wells.

Well drillers write reports describing the rock and sediment each well passes through. The U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) built its 2019 three-dimensional picture of the valley’s underground layers mainly from 291 of these reports. USGS published the well data separately, in a 2020 data release linked from the report. We counted 290 wells in its well-location file and the same 290 in its rock-description file.

We have not found the reason for the gap, and one well by itself does not mean the geology is wrong. Coverage is uneven: 259 of the 290 wells have construction details, and 252 have water-level readings. The report notes few wells north of Parma and in the southeast part of the area it mapped. It also says fewer wells reach deep layers, so the picture is less certain with depth.

Research details and original wording

Record reference: PILOT-CLM-009

Original statement

USGS reports that the framework was generated primarily from lithologic information compiled from 291 well-driller reports. After excluding CSV section markers, the released location and lithology tables contain the same 290 unique bore names; the discrepancy remains unresolved.

extracted
preliminary
Confidence: High for method count stated in the abstract.
Human review required
Claim details
Primary geography
Unknown
Time period covered
Framework published 2019, version 1.1 January 2020; mixed historical well records, no single observation date
Metric
Reported driller inputs versus released unique bore identities
Unit
291 reported inputs; 290 released bore names after excluding CSV section markers
Caveat
Historical pilot caveat: The released files were derived from the same inputs, not independent corroboration. Construction, water-level and comment coverage is incomplete across the 290 released names; no uniform sampling coverage is implied. P06/P07/P25 reconcile the 291 reported inputs with 290 released identities, then inspect selection criteria and source driller records before site-level conclusions. P33 access update, September 29, 2026: full PDF is available and the cited text was inspected. Earlier retrieval-only requests are superseded; scientific, version, spatial and visual limits remain. No model rerun or confidence upgrade.
Why it matters
Not recorded
Verification needed
Reconcile 291 inputs with 290 released identities, selection criteria and original driller records before site-level conclusions.
Geographies
Treasure Valley and surrounding area, Idaho and Oregon
Tests hypotheses

Not linked to a hypothesis yet.

Documentary qualifications

Original wording is preserved below. Source attribution is not independent verification. Missing information is shown as Unknown.

Documentary claim ID
PILOT-CLM-009
Original claim text
USGS reports that the framework was generated primarily from lithologic information compiled from 291 well-driller reports. After excluding CSV section markers, the released location and lithology tables contain the same 290 unique bore names; the discrepancy remains unresolved.
Original source ID
SRC-000053
Source owner
USGS
Authority tier
Tier 3 - Scientific/technical synthesis
Claim type
Historical model input-count discrepancy
Original geography
Treasure Valley and surrounding area, Idaho and Oregon.
Original time period
Framework published 2019, version 1.1 January 2020; mixed historical well records, no single observation date
Original metric
Reported driller inputs versus released unique bore identities
Original unit
291 reported inputs; 290 released bore names after excluding CSV section markers
Water accounting type
N/A; hydrogeologic input lineage
Legal instrument type
N/A; scientific framework
Preliminary confidence
High for marker-excluded file counts; input-count reconciliation remains unresolved.
Original caveat
Historical pilot caveat: The released files were derived from the same inputs, not independent corroboration. Construction, water-level and comment coverage is incomplete across the 290 released names; no uniform sampling coverage is implied. P06/P07/P25 reconcile the 291 reported inputs with 290 released identities, then inspect selection criteria and source driller records before site-level conclusions. P33 access update, September 29, 2026: full PDF is available and the cited text was inspected. Earlier retrieval-only requests are superseded; scientific, version, spatial and visual limits remain. No model rerun or confidence upgrade.
Original verification needed
Reconcile 291 inputs with 290 released identities, selection criteria and original driller records before site-level conclusions.
Evidence for the claim
Source record: SRC-000053; canonical URL: https://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/sir20195138. Original locator: [2026-09-26 evidence supplement](treasure_valley_model_framework_inspection.md#pilot-clm-009); report access and file/table locators are explicit there. Provenance: [Original PILOT-CLM-009](boise_payette_treasure_valley_10_source_extraction_pilot.md#pilot-clm-009), original line 182. Normalized September 29, 2026; original inspection history retained in the linked file. P33 reconciliation: Framework version 1.1, PDF p. 9 / printed p. 1, Abstract and PDF p. 17 / printed p. 9, modeling methods; the 290-count release locators remain in the September 26 supplement. Report: https://pubs.usgs.gov/sir/2019/5138/sir20195138_v1.1.pdf. Full PDF retrieved September 28, 2026 in [P25 evidence pack](../14_draft_outputs/basin_source_set__Boise_Payette_Treasure_Valley.md); selected native text checked again September 29.
Evidence against and limitations
No independent counter-evidence established in this extraction. Reconcile 291 inputs with 290 released identities, selection criteria and original driller records before site-level conclusions.
Related basin
Treasure Valley aquifer system,western Snake River Plain aquifer system
Related cross-cutting systems
measurement,models,accounting
Original documentary status
Preliminary; needs verification; normalized September 29, 2026
Sources behind this statement
Mapping the ground beneath the Treasure Valley

preliminary_claims.jsonl#PILOT-CLM-009