The 2025 cleanup review for two phosphate plants
Ready to paste into a message or email.
Copy this address: https://idahowaterstatus.com/research/sources/SRC-000516
What this source tells us
In 2025, federal regulators again found the Simplot plant cleanup near Pocatello does not yet protect river life. They know of no drinking water wells that draw from the polluted groundwater.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) reviews this Superfund site, about 2.5 miles northwest of Pocatello, every five years. This third review covers September 2024 to September 2025. EPA rated the cleanup at Simplot’s Don Plant “Not Protective.” Polluted groundwater still flows into the Portneuf River, carrying phosphorus above the state’s target. This continues even though Simplot pumps groundwater and has added controls at pollution sources. The former FMC Corporation plant next door is rated “Will be Protective” once a planned groundwater treatment system is built. In 2020, EPA rated both cleanups not protective.
Groundwater under both plants has pollutants above federal drinking water limits. At Simplot, releases from aging or failing plant equipment are still raising pollution in groundwater, sometimes above hazardous levels. EPA asked Simplot to pump out more groundwater with new wells and treat it if needed. EPA also wants Simplot to send its equipment inspection reports and keep testing groundwater.
Phosphorus in the river has dropped a great deal since cleanup began at Simplot, but the river’s water quality is still poor. Phosphorus did not meet the state’s target by its December 31, 2021 deadline. Simplot expected to meet the target by mid-2026, and EPA said river testing must confirm it.
Selected passages read · Summary checked November 6, 2026
How this summary was checked
-
Contents and protectiveness statements/recommendations, printed page 46 / PDF page 47; reference list identifies underlying monitoring periods.
Open the referenced material (opens in a new tab)
Read the original source (opens a new tab)
Source details and citation information
Record reference: SRC-000516
Catalog title: Eastern Michaud Flats Contamination Superfund Site — third five-year review, 2025
- Owner
- EPA (Federal agency)
- Source authority
- Tier 2 - Official interpretation/operations
- Source type
- PDF report
- Period covered
- 2025 review; official progress table records September 23, 2025 completion
- Publication date
- Unknown
- Geography
- Michaud Flats, Power/Bannock Counties, Idaho; project, aquifer, cleanup and Tribal extents differ
- Update cadence
- Static / legal / historical
- Water accounting type
- Unknown
- Provisional status
- Mixed
- Primary use
- P29 Michaud Flats qualified source coverage
- Known caveats
- Overview statement that cleanup is effective cannot replace OU-specific determinations on PDF p.47. OU3 excludes groundwater/river and OU5 is outside this review. July 2028 recommendations are not a cleanup-completion guarantee. Operator plans to start construction in 2026 are not verified completion; signature image and full appendices unreviewed.
- Human review
- Required
No claims cite this source yet.
No linked holdings.