Skip to content
Source summary

2023 filing on how much city water is used up and how much returns

Ready to paste into a message or email.

Copy this address: https://idahowaterstatus.com/research/sources/SRC-000564

What this source tells us

Two 2022 state orders count all new city water use as used up. A Veolia expert put the yearly share at about half.

In 2022 the Idaho Department of Water Resources (IDWR) issued two moratorium orders. One, dated May 17, covers the Big Wood River Ground Water Management Area. The other, an amended order dated October 21, covers the Snake River Basin. Both say applications for municipal water use “shall be considered fully consumptive.” That means IDWR counts all the water as used up, with none going back to rivers or aquifers. Maximilian C. Bricker, a lawyer for the City of Pocatello, filed this sworn statement with IDWR on August 30, 2023. It backs a motion by the municipal water providers. It attaches expert reports for those providers, for Veolia and for the Surface Water Coalition. It also attaches a deposition of IDWR’s James Cefalo.

Veolia’s report is a July 11, 2023 memo by Terry Scanlan, a consulting engineer. It calls the fully consumptive policy “not factually accurate.” It argues that most of Veolia’s water not used for irrigation flows back to the Boise River through the city’s wastewater plants. It estimates that about 9% of that water is used up. Over a full year, counting irrigation, it puts the share at about half. Under a 100% policy, Veolia could owe about twice as much replacement water as it actually uses up, the memo says. This is one party’s expert view, not an IDWR finding. Its facility data come from Suez Water Idaho’s May 2022 master facilities plan. That plan leaves out the parts of Eagle that Veolia had recently added by buying Eagle Water Company.

Selected passages read · Summary checked November 6, 2026

How this summary was checked

Read the original source (opens a new tab)

Source details and citation information

Record reference: SRC-000564

Catalog title: Affidavit of Maximilian C. Bricker in Support of Municipal Providers’ Motion for Partial Summary Judgment; Exhibit 3: Municipal Water Right Consumptive Use Policy

Needs review
PDF report
Overview
Owner
Municipal providers filing; Exhibit 3 by Terry Scanlan, HDR, for Veolia counsel; hosted by IDWR
Source authority
Tier 4 - Stakeholder/media/commentary
Source type
PDF report
Period covered
August 30, 2023 affidavit; July 11, 2023 expert memo citing May 2022 facilities plan
Publication date
August 30, 2023
Geography
Veolia Water Idaho; Boise and portions of Ada County; document-specific boundaries
Update cadence
Static / legal / historical
Water accounting type
Unknown
Provisional status
Stakeholder claim
Caveats & use
Primary use
Stakeholder position
Known caveats
Secondary evidence of facilities-plan identity and scope only. Full 2022 plan not obtained. Expert advocacy is not agency adoption or current firm-capacity evidence; consumptive-use opinions not adjudicated here.
Human review
Required
Claims citing this source

No claims cite this source yet.

Linked bibliographic holdings

No linked holdings.